Are Plantains Better Than Rice for a Diet?
Plantains, a starchy fruit related to the banana, and rice are both high-carbohydrate foods and dense sources of calories. Which one works the best with your diet depends on the specific diet you are following. In moderation, however, both of these nonfat foods can be a good fit in a healthy diet.
Calories and Macronutrients
Plantains have slightly more calories than white rice. A cup of plantains provides 232 calories while a cup of white rice provides 205. Both plantains and rice are high in carbohydrates. Plantains have 62 g of carbohydrates, while rice has 44 g. Plantains contain 28 g of sugars, while rice has none. Keep in mind that starchy foods such as rice and plantains both convert to sugars after they are ingested. If you are counting carbohydrates, rice is your best option, as it has fewer carbs. Instead of choosing white rice, however, opt for a 1 cup serving of brown rice, which provides 216 calories and 44 g carbs.
- Plantains have slightly more calories than white rice.
- Plantains have 62 g of carbohydrates, while rice has 44 g. Plantains contain 28 g of sugars, while rice has none.
The Calories in Plantains
Some diets emphasize the glycemic index score of foods. The glycemic index measures how much a particular food affects blood glucose levels. If you want your blood sugar to be steady, which has the effect of reducing cravings, your best choice is plantains. Boiled green plantains have a GI of 41, while white and brown rice both have a GI as high as 89. Ripe plantains have a glycemic index equal to rice, however, and you will want to avoid them along with rice on a low-glycemic-index diet.
- Some diets emphasize the glycemic index score of foods.
- Ripe plantains have a glycemic index equal to rice, however, and you will want to avoid them along with rice on a low-glycemic-index diet.
Fiber helps to provide satiety, and can help you stick to a diet. Eating an additional 14 g of fiber each day helped research subjects consume 10 percent fewer calories and lose weight, according to Nancy Howarth, author of "Dietary Fiber and Weight Regulation." In a comparison of white rice and plantain, the plantain comes out ahead with almost 5 g of fiber. Brown rice, on the other hand, has only 1 g less fiber per serving than plantains, making it a healthy choice as well. To get the filling effects of fiber in your diet, pass on the white rice and choose brown rice or plantains.
- Fiber helps to provide satiety, and can help you stick to a diet.
- In a comparison of white rice and plantain, the plantain comes out ahead with almost 5 g of fiber.
The Health Benefits of Kasha
If you decide to include plantains as part of a healthy diet, you will need to pay careful attention to how they are prepared. Plantains are often fried or mashed with lard or other fats, which dramatically boosts their calorie content. For example, the popular plantain dish mofongo consists of plantains and cracklings, and has over 350 calories per 3 oz. serving. Choose boiled plantains, and add minimal amounts of fat to the dish. Rice is often served plain, but Mexican and Chinese-American cuisines frequently include fried rice dishes. Avoid fried rice, and choose plain brown rice for the best blood sugar control and overall calorie count.
- If you decide to include plantains as part of a healthy diet, you will need to pay careful attention to how they are prepared.
- Plantains are often fried or mashed with lard or other fats, which dramatically boosts their calorie content.
The Calories in Plantains
The Health Benefits of Kasha
How Much Fiber Is in Rice Bran?
How to Plan Glycemic Load Menu
Is Rice Good If You Are on a Low-fat Diet?
Can Diabetics Eat Rye Bread & Pumpernickel Bread?
Foods to Avoid on the SureSlim Diet
The Effects of Brown Rice Syrup on Blood Sugar
A Diverticulitis Diet Without Wheat
Figs for Weight Loss
- United States Department of Agriculture: Nutrient Data Laboratory
- Glycemic Index Foundation: Home of the Glycemic Index
- LIVESTRONG MyPlate: Mofongo
- "Nutrition Reviews"; Dietary Fiber and Weight Regulation; Nancy Howarth; 2001
- Puerto Rican favorites made healthy. Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. Updated 2018.
- Green plantains, boiled. FoodData Central. U.S. Department of Agriculture. Published April 1, 2019.
- Oladele EO, Williamson G. Impact of resistant starch in three plantain (Musa AAB) products on glycaemic response of healthy volunteers. Eur J Nutr. 2016;55(1):75-81. doi:10.1007/s00394-014-0825-6
- Famakin O, Fatoyinbo A, Ijarotimi OS, Badejo AA, Fagbemi TN. Assessment of nutritional quality, glycaemic index, antidiabetic and sensory properties of plantain ()-based functional dough meals. J Food Sci Technol. 2016;53(11):3865-3875. doi:10.1007/s13197-016-2357-y
- Blomme G, Ocimati W, Nabuuma D, et al. Pro-vitamin A carotenoid content of 48 plantain (Musa AAB genome) cultivars sourced from eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. J Sci Food Agric. 2020;100(2):634-647. doi:10.1002/jsfa.10058
- McKinney C. What is resistant starch?. The John Hopkins Patient Guide to Diabetes.
- Potassium fact sheet for health professionals. National Institutes of Health. Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated 2020.
- Iron fact sheet for health professionals. National Institutes of Health. Office of Dietary Supplements. Updated 2020.
- Banana. Anaphylaxis Campaign. Updated 2018.
- The Editors of the Encyclopedia Britannica. Plantain. Encyclopedia Britannica. Updated 2019.
- Fruits and Veggies! Half Your Plate. Plantain. Canadian Public Health Association. Updated 2020.
Elise Wile has been a writer since 2003. Holding a master's degree in curriculum and Instruction, she has written training materials for three school districts. Her expertise includes mentoring, serving at-risk students and corporate training.