Health Concerns for Silicone Ice Trays Vs. Plastic Ice Trays

Fact Checked

iJupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images

Plastic ice cube trays have been a popular choice for many years; they are cheap, reusable and convenient. Recent concerns about chemicals in plastics that can leach into foods have raised questions about the impact on health from using plastic ice cube trays. Silicone ice cube trays are an alternative to plastic. They became available in recent years.

What are Plastic and Silicone?

Plastic and silicone are two materials often considered to be similar, but in fact have some very important differences. Plastic is a synthetic made of a number of different polymers; as a result; several different types of plastics are on the market. All plastic items are marked with a number on the bottom that indicates the type of plastic. Silicone, although it resembles a plastic and is also synthetic, is quite different. Silicone is a pliable, sterile resin that to date has shown no signs of leaching anything into foods or liquids.

Plastic Ice Trays

Manufacturers make plastic ice trays of a hard plastic, and some of these plastics do contain BPA, the chemical shown to carry a health risk. Since the information about BPA became public, many plastics companies have released new versions of their plastic ice cube trays that are BPA free. If your ice cube trays are more than a few years old, odds are good they contain BPA. The change to BPA free plastics does not necessarily mean they are safe and won't leach chemicals, only that they will not leach BPA.

Dangers of BPA in Ice Trays

BPA has been shown to cause health concerns in unborn babies, children and even adults. Some of the problems associated with BPA include damage to the brain, behavioral changes and damage to the pituitary gland. Other concerns are considered to be a lower risk. The risk of BPA leaching into foods or liquids is highest when the plastic is heated. The odds of it leaching into ice is therefore relatively low. Many people use ice cube trays for other purposes ,however, that may lead to a higher risk. Putting hot baby food or other hot liquids or purees into ice cube trays could heat the plastic enough to cause some leaching.

Silicone Ice Trays

Some studies consider silicone to be a safer alternative to plastic because there is no risk of chemical leaching. Silicone is sterile and does not break down as easily as plastic, making it more durable. Currently, there is no known health danger of using silicone ice trays, but since its use fairly recently, we may not know some things about silicone.