05 December, 2018
Glycolic Acid vs. Retin-A
People commonly use chemical peels and retinoids to combat acne or improve their appearance after suffering skin damage caused by the sun. Retin-A is one of many vitamin A-based drugs called retinoids, and is a brand name for a drug called tretinoin. Glycolic acid is a natural acid that is found in sugar cane. It is used in chemical peels. Both glycolic acid and Retin-A cause the top layer of skin to peel off, generate new skin growth, unclog pores and remove dead skin cells.
A glycolic acid peel is often applied following treatment with a retinoid such as Retin-A, according to the Mayo Clinic. The pre-treatment with Retin-A can last up to six weeks. This allows for better penetration with the chemical peel. Retin-A is often combined with oral antibiotics that kill acne bacteria.
Home vs. Office
It is best to have a trained health professional administer glycolic acid, recommends the Mayo Clinic. Treatment lasts three to 20 minutes, and the patient is often given a sedative when treated. A patient undergoes four to six peels that are done one to two weeks apart. The peel removes a portion of the patient’s outer layer of skin. Retin-A is available with a doctor’s prescription, and the patient applies it at home each night, usually before bedtime, and washes it off in the morning. Retin-A also allows the top layer of skin to peel off, but it can take seven weeks to see effects, according to Baptist Health Systems in Jackson, Miss.
Retin-A is the most commonly used retinoid used in skin care, according to Harvard Medical School. Glycolic acid is among the mildest acids that are used to do chemical peels. Mild acids are used for peels classified as “superficial” as opposed to “medium” or “deep.”
Both Retin-A and glycolic acid can be used to treat fine wrinkles, hyperpigmentation and brown spots. Glycolic acid is also commonly used to reduce appearance of acne scars. With Retin-A, improvements in the appearance of photodamage can be seen after three to six months of regular use, and best results show up between six and 12 months. With glycolic acid, “maintenance” peels are recommended monthly to maintain results once these are achieved, according to the Mayo Clinic.
A glycolic acid peel will make skin pink for up to 24 hours while it heals. A person will experience a stinging sensation while the peel is being done, and must mist skin with water and use cold compresses and moisturizers following the procedure. A person who uses Retin-A must use moisturizers as well as sunscreen, as the drug makes the skin more sensitive to the sun.
Glycolic acid side effects can include blisters, temporary redness, scaling, skin color changes, scarring and infection. Retin-A side effects, aside from sun sensitivity, include severe dryness of the skin, redness, peeling, skin color changes and an initial acne flare-up that usually dissipates with further use, according to the Mayo Clinic.
- Jupiterimages/Comstock/Getty Images